The dirt on Cincinnati, Part One
I have decided that the best way to share this horrible saga is to reprint parts of the letter I sent to the woman who was "just a platonic friend" of his, who turned out to more, although Cincinnati* was running hot and cold on her in similar fashion. And yes, I did rat him out to her, but only after I dumped him.
Although I don't think Cincinnati is a full-blown narcissist, he certainly has some similarities. I think he's closer to emotionally unavailable, although his months of messages to me suggested the opposite.
Anyway, here goes with Part One. It will eventually become obvious as to why I made the decision to write a letter to this woman, so bear with me.
Part One of the Letter
*******
Before I begin, I want to apologize for writing you out of the blue. But I have just gone through a miserable month with our mutual acquaintance Cincinnati, who I had a relationship with since 2010 (mostly online, with a couple of gaps and real-time visits). I recently discovered that he lied to me about some things, and two of the more blatant and upsetting lies concern you.
Since our relationship went on for nine years, it'll take me a while to provide an accurate picture (although some following pages are all screen grabs).
(I'm going to cut out the history as it's already been mentioned earlier on this blog.)
After my 2017 visit and breakup with Cincinnati the following month, almost a year went by with no contact. By now, I had moved my mother near my rental to care for her. She died in hospice in February 2018. Later that year I decided to leave Texas as I had no family left here, and I hated the weather.
While packing, I found a saint's medallion I'd bought for Cincinnati in 2017 that hadn't arrived in time to give to him during my 2017 visit. I decided to mail it to him, explaining why I was mailing it after so long with no contact. I didn't expect a response, but I was pleasantly surprised when he contacted me immediately, saying he sorry I'd lost my mother.
We began to chat again online, hesitantly at first. He eventually steered the to our mutual love of retro lingerie, and how we needed to get together so he could dress me in corsets and hosiery and garters. We spent hours online talking about our immense good fortune, and how we had despaired of ever meeting anyone who shared our interests. Many mornings, he would wittily invite me to have a shower with him online. We also chatted for hours about our next meeting.
Since I hadn't forgotten the disastrous 2017 visit, I insisted that I would only visit if he invited me. He kept mentioning this would happen, although he dropped hints on Instagram that I shouldn't postpone.
By this time, I was again smitten with him. In July he ordered over $100 of hosiery in preparation for my visit, and even posted a screen grab of the receipt.
(I parked screen grabs of the receipt here for her perusal, and his asking me for my size.)
In mid-July I drove to Tennessee for an extended visit with my aunt. I also visited Columbus, Ohio to scope out possible jobs. I hadn't yet decided to move there, but it was one of several locations I was considering. Cincinnati knew all about this. Although he did not specifically invite me to Ohio, he said he would make every effort to visit me in Columbus.
(here was a screen grab of an Instagram chat, where he says he'll visit me in Columbus.)
During my initial drive to Columbus in mid-July, I passed Cincinnati's condo by a few miles. We messaged about my stopping for an hour or two (bringing hosiery with me), but we decided to wait.
This is when things with Cincinnati began to get strange. It was if there were two different Cincinnatis.
Although he sounded desperate to meet me when I got to Ohio (I have over 150 archived conversations), they never happened. I began to notice that he talked about you constantly on Strava and posted photos of the two of you. So I began to wonder if you two were dating, since he was spending his spare time with you instead of me.
After a weekend when he had discussed getting together on a Sunday afternoon after a ride, but then going quiet and then posting pics of you all over Strava, I wrote him an email. I suggested we meet and simply chat. I got this email reply from him.
If there are nerves or doubts, perhaps we need to wait. It's been easy to get caught up in certain moments and discussions with you. Obviously it can be easier to express particular thoughts or feelings through this media compared than in person. I'm sure neither of us desire any regrets. More time might be what's best for both of us.
This was nothing like his romantic Instagram messages and I didn't know how to respond. But eventually I wrote back and suggested we meet. He accepted this coldly and sent me a short note. "I'll be in touch". I was hurt, so I responded and said that I felt I had pressured him, and suggested we postpone meeting for a while. He didn't respond.
I eventually sent him a second email. I said that I felt that our meeting was more of a priority for me than for him, because he kept making choices how he spent his free time, and I was never his choice.
No response.
I eventually sent a third email and politely said that if you two were dating, he should be honest about it. I would bow out and let you two proceed with a relationship.
He answered the third one. He said that your relationship was platonic and you were a friend. In a few days, his Instagram messages became passionate again and he insisted we should meet before I left Ohio. Also, your photos stopped appearing all over his Strava app.
(Herewith ends Part One. The awful Part Two will appear later this week.)